New York moving guide
Where should I move in New York?
We ranked 87 New York cities with 20,000+ residents on home affordability (income vs. home value), unemployment, education and population growth. Here are the top 15.
See New York in Numbers dashboard →- 194/100NiskayunaHome $357,900 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Rent $1,589 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Income $134,052 · ACS unemployment 3.1%
- 285/100BrightonHome $282,100 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Rent $1,350 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Income $85,467 · ACS unemployment 3.9%
- 380/100West IslipHome $756,393 (Zillow ZHVI · 2026-10-31) · Rent $2,765 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Income $176,281 · ACS unemployment 3.7%
- 478/100Deer ParkHome $669,826 (Zillow ZHVI · 2026-10-31) · Rent $2,438 (Zillow ZORI · 2026-10-31) · Income $137,105 · ACS unemployment 2.2%
- 577/100East MassapequaHome $625,600 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Rent $1,486 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Income $146,454 · ACS unemployment 4.4%
- 675/100IrondequoitHome $182,500 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Rent $1,159 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Income $79,162 · ACS unemployment 4.4%
- 774/100BaldwinHome $730,832 (Zillow ZHVI · 2026-10-31) · Rent $1,890 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Income $145,472 · ACS unemployment 4.3%
- 873/100CommackHome $816,313 (Zillow ZHVI · 2026-10-31) · Rent $5,749 (Zillow ZORI · 2026-10-31) · Income $169,792 · ACS unemployment 4.6%
- 969/100MineolaHome $843,496 (Zillow ZHVI · 2026-10-31) · Rent $3,727 (Zillow ZORI · 2026-10-31) · Income $137,739 · ACS unemployment 3.2%
- 1069/100Tonawanda TownHome $215,200 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Rent $1,102 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Income $77,679 · ACS unemployment 3.5%
- 1168/100Garden CityHome $1,406,727 (Zillow ZHVI · 2026-10-31) · Rent $6,343 (Zillow ZORI · 2026-09-30) · Income $244,152 · ACS unemployment 3.9%
- 1268/100North AmityvilleHome $466,500 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Rent $2,467 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Income $136,654 · ACS unemployment 4.8%
- 1367/100MerrickHome $905,663 (Zillow ZHVI · 2026-10-31) · Rent $2,919 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Income $185,740 · ACS unemployment 3.9%
- 1466/100Saratoga SpringsHome $653,303 (Zillow ZHVI · 2026-10-31) · Rent $2,125 (Zillow ZORI · 2026-10-31) · Income $105,944 · ACS unemployment 2.5%
- 1565/100East PatchogueHome $478,700 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Rent $2,045 (Census ACS · 2020–2024) · Income $108,397 · ACS unemployment 5.4%
Statewide, New York recorded 1,933 crimes per 100,000 people in 2025 — #19 highest of 50 states (FBI).
Also see: Best counties in New York to live
Sources, periods & methodology
Population, household income, unemployment and education use Census ACS 2020–2024 five-year estimates. Education includes bachelor’s, master’s, professional and doctorate degrees among adults aged 25+. ACS unemployment is a survey-period estimate, not the latest monthly BLS rate.
Population changes compare overlapping 2019–2023 and 2020–2024 survey periods; they are not one-year population growth or measured migration. Margins of error are not shown, so small differences may not be statistically meaningful.
Housing identifies its source and period beside the figure: Zillow ZHVI typical home values and ZORI rent indexes where matched; otherwise explicitly labelled ACS median owner-occupied home value or median gross rent. These are not current listings, sale prices, appraisals or guaranteed rents. Zillow year-over-year change is shown only for a matched Zillow series.
The research score equally weights within-state percentiles for income relative to home value, lower survey unemployment, degree attainment and population-estimate change. Ties share a midpoint percentile; missing metrics receive a neutral 50th percentile. Scores are screening aids, not an overall safety rating, school ranking or investment recommendation.
FBI Crime Data Explorer figures identify their reporting year; statewide rates are context, not city or neighborhood rates. Missing reporting is not zero. Confirm the exact address and current conditions before acting.
Home listings, local news, migration, schools, resources and the Smart Movers Grade & Verdict.
See the full Smart Movers Club report on Niskayuna